I didn’t think anyone could dethrone the Emmy burger as the best burger in town, but leave it to a player from meat-and-potatoes town Chicago to show the New York City burgers how it’s done. That title now belongs to the American Cheeseburger at 4 Charles Prime Rib, which is run by the restaurateur behind Chicago’s famous Au Cheval. I’ve never been to Au Cheval, but apparently the burger there is to die for, and if the burger at 4 Charles Prime Rib is any indication, I should be dead by now.Read More
I’m going to keep this blog post short and sweet – I went to Umami Burger for lunch today and it totally lives up to the hype. Correction – it transcended the hype. Forget any lunch plans that you’ve made for the week. Reschedule for lunch at Umami. Yes, we’ve heard about the epic 2 hour waits, but the crowds have thinned down a bit post Labor Day. During the work week, a wait for a table of 2 at prime lunch hour was a reasonable 20 minutes. Yes, it’s a work week, but do whatever you can to make it happen. Schedule some sort of “team-building” event at Umami so that work people don’t get mad. Your role as the culture carrier will win you some points, and everyone will be so excited to eat these awesome burgers. Wins all around.
I was torn between the Original and the Truffle burger, but decided that I needed to judge the merits of this restaurant based on what initially made them famous. The server recommended that I order it medium rare, and I gladly complied.
Wow–this burger left me speechless. The way the succulent juices of the flavorful patty soaked into the delicious and buttery toasted bun was incredible. Even something simple like the house ketchup was amazing. Somehow it really brought out the extremely satisfying savory flavors of a hamburger. The parmesan crisp was a unique touch that added some salty, sharp notes to the burger. I loved the variety of textures provided by the different vegetables, as well as the subtle earthy, sweet and and tangy flavors they lent. This hamburger deserves to be awarded with the amazeballs label. I can’t wait to go back and try the Truffle burger. Unfortunately Umami doesn’t offer takeout, so a long weekend wait or an aggressive weekday lunch is in order. Don’t be surprised if I schedule a “coffee chat” over burgers in the West Village sometime in the near future.
— Umami Burger 432 6th Ave. (between 9th and 10th St.) New York, NY 10011 (212) 677-8626